Best Indianapolis Gifts: 10 Ideas for Indy Lovers in 2026
Ten of the best Indianapolis gifts for any occasion — from a 3D skyline of Monument Circle to St. Elmo sauce, Speedway history and Mass Ave art.
Best Indianapolis Gifts: 10 Ideas for Indy Lovers in 2026
Quick answer: The best Indianapolis gifts are a 3D Indianapolis skyline sculpture ($34.99–$74.99), St. Elmo shrimp cocktail sauce, Indy 500 memorabilia from the Speedway Museum, a sugar cream pie, and art from Mass Ave.
10 best Indianapolis gifts
1. 3D Indianapolis skyline sculpture. Salesforce Tower, OneAmerica Tower, the Statehouse dome and the Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument in matte black. View the model.
2. St. Elmo shrimp cocktail sauce. The city's most famous flavor, in a bottle.
3. Indy 500 memorabilia. A vintage poster or scale car from the Speedway Museum.
4. Sugar cream pie. Indiana's state pie, for the food lover.
5. Mass Ave art prints. Local artists, local landmarks.
6. Throwback Pacers gear. History beats this season's roster.
7. Sun King glassware. A downtown craft brewery since 2009.
8. Kurt Vonnegut Museum goods. For the reader.
9. Newfields LOVE print. Robert Indiana's famous design.
10. Indianapolis City Market gift basket. Local honey, sauces and treats.
Which one to pick
For a gift that lasts and fits any taste, choose the Indianapolis skyline. For a quick add-on, pair it with a bottle of St. Elmo sauce.
Related: Best Indianapolis souvenirs · Indianapolis skyline gift ideas