Unique Indianapolis Gifts Under $100: 12 Ideas That Don't Feel Cheap (2026)
Twelve unique Indianapolis gifts under $100 — a 3D skyline of Monument Circle, St. Elmo sauce, Speedway memorabilia, Mass Ave art and more, with real price ranges.
Unique Indianapolis Gifts Under $100: 12 Ideas That Don't Feel Cheap
Quick answer: The best unique Indianapolis gift under $100 is a 3D Indianapolis skyline sculpture ($34.99–$74.99). Other strong picks: St. Elmo cocktail sauce (under $15), a sugar cream pie (around $20), a Speedway Museum poster ($20–$40) and Mass Ave art prints ($25–$60).
Under $25
1. St. Elmo shrimp cocktail sauce. The city's signature flavor.
2. A sugar cream pie. Indiana's state pie.
3. Sun King glassware. Local craft beer pride.
4. A Kurt Vonnegut paperback from the museum. Literary and local.
$25 to $50
5. A small 3D Indianapolis skyline. A desk-size version of the Indy model.
6. A Speedway Museum vintage poster. Racing history, framed.
7. A Mass Ave art print. Local artists, local landmarks.
8. Throwback Pacers T-shirt. ABA history.
$50 to $100
9. A Large 3D Indianapolis skyline. The 9-inch version for a mantel. See sizes.
10. A Newfields membership. A year of gardens and art.
11. A St. Elmo gift card. Dinner at a 1902 institution.
12. A Fountain Square maker gift set. Ceramics and candles from local makers.
Why the skyline is the best value
At $34.99–$74.99, the Indianapolis skyline is the rare gift under $100 that's both specific to the city and permanent.
Related: Indianapolis souvenirs that aren't tacky · Indianapolis Christmas gift guide